Marriage is meant to be a lifelong partnership, but what happens when one or both spouses are fundamentally incapable of fulfilling their marital duties? For some, the issue isn’t just incompatibility or a failing relationship—it’s something deeper and more serious. In the Philippines, the law provides a remedy for marriages that were never valid from the start through a declaration of nullity.

One of the most commonly used grounds is “psychological incapacity”, but what does this really mean? How does the law define it, and what do recent Supreme Court decisions say about it? Let’s break it down.

What is Psychological Incapacity?

Psychological incapacity refers to a person’s inability to comply with the essential obligations of marriage due to a deeply rooted mental or personality disorder. Unlike annulment, which applies to marriages that are valid until declared voidable, nullity of marriage under Article 36 means that the marriage was never valid from the start (void ab initio).

Many misconceptions surround psychological incapacity. It is not just about being irresponsible or immature, or having an affair or being unfaithful, or irreconcilable differences, or having frequent arguments, or incompatibility. Instead, it must be a serious, incurable condition that existed at the time of marriage, making one or both spouses unable to fulfill their marital duties.

Supreme Court Interpretations: The Legal Concept of Psychological Incapacity

The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that psychological incapacity is a legal concept rather than a medical one. It does not require a clinical diagnosis, but rather clear acts of dysfunctionality that demonstrate an inability to comply with essential marital obligations. In Tan-Andal v. Andal, G.R. No. 196359 (2021), the Supreme Court stated:

“Psychological incapacity consists of clear acts of dysfunctionality that show a lack of understanding and concomitant compliance with one’s essential marital obligations due to psychic causes. It is not a medical illness that has to be medically or clinically identified; hence, expert opinion is not required.”

This means that even without a psychiatrist’s diagnosis, a spouse’s incapacity to perform marital obligations can still be proven through behavioral evidence and testimonies.

The Court further explained in Dela Cruz-Lanuza v. Lanuza, Jr., G.R. No. 242362 (2024) the “durable personality structure” of one suffering from psychological incapacity:

“Psychological incapacity is a durable or enduring aspect of a person’s personality called ‘personality structure,’ which manifests itself through clear acts of dysfunctionality that undermine the family.”

The spouse’s personality structure must make it impossible for him or her to understand and fulfill essential marital obligations.

In Republic of the Philippines v. Claur, G.R. No. 246868 (2022), the Supreme Court reiterated three essential elements of psychological incapacity – Gravity, Incurability, and Juridical Antecedence. The incapacity must be grave in that it is serious and not just mild character flaws or mood swings. It must be incurable in that the condition cannot be remedied, either medically or legally, within the context of the marriage. And it must have juridical antecedents in that the incapacity must exist at the time of the marriage ceremony.

These rulings make it easier for spouses to seek nullity since they no longer need to rely solely on medical evidence.

How to Prove Psychological Incapacity

If you are considering filing for nullity of marriage based on psychological incapacity, here’s what you need to do:

1. Establish a clear narrative – Demonstrate how the psychological incapacity is grave, incurable, and existed at the time of marriage. The story should highlight specific behaviors that prove an inability to fulfill marital obligations.

2. Gather witness testimonies – Statements from family members, colleagues, or close friends who have firsthand knowledge of your spouse’s behavior can strengthen your case.

3. Present supporting evidence – Document consistent patterns of dysfunction, such as emotional detachment, financial irresponsibility, neglect, or an inability to communicate effectively within the marriage.

4. Consider psychological evaluations – While no longer required, assessments from mental health professionals can still provide valuable insights and reinforce your claims.

5. Distinguish between psychological incapacity and marital issues – Not all unhappy marriages qualify. The incapacity must be a deep-seated and incurable condition, not merely personality differences, incompatibility, or infidelity.

6. Secure relevant documentation early – Collect personal records, messages, testimonies, and other forms of evidence that can help illustrate the presence of psychological incapacity from the start of the marriage.

By following these steps, you can build a strong case for nullity based on psychological incapacity and navigate the legal process more effectively.

Common Questions About Nullity of Marriage

1. Can I file for nullity just because my spouse cheated on me?

No. Infidelity alone does not amount to psychological incapacity unless it is tied to a deeper, incurable disorder that prevents the spouse from fulfilling marital obligations.

2. How long does a nullity case take?

It depends on the complexity of the case, the availability of evidence, and court schedules. Some cases take one to three years.

3. If my marriage is declared null, what happens to my children?

Children born within a void marriage are still considered legitimate under the law. Child custody, support, and visitation rights will be settled separately.

4. What is the difference between annulment and nullity of marriage?

Annulment applies to marriages that were valid but can be voided due to defects such as fraud or lack of parental consent.

Nullity of marriage applies to marriages that were void from the beginning due to reasons such as psychological incapacity.

Final Thoughts: Know Your Rights

The Supreme Court’s recent rulings liberalized the rules for individuals trapped in psychologically incapacitated marriages to seek legal relief. The shift towards a totality of evidence approach means that more real-life circumstances can be considered without relying solely on a psychological report.

If you or someone you know is considering filing for the nullity of marriage, it’s important to consult a lawyer to understand the legal options available. Every case is different, and proper legal guidance can make all the difference.

#MarriageNullity #PsychologicalIncapacity #FamilyLaw #KnowYourRights #LegalGuide